Top 10 Best Ice Cream Makers for The Money- Buying Guide in 2020

0

Everybody loves a big bowl of ice cream –and nothing’s sweeter than whipping up your homemade ice cream during summertime. Sometimes you need to cool yourself on a sunny hot day by having an ice cream. You can get one easily from a nearby super shop. But you are unable to control the quality of ingredients while it’s possible using a home ice cream maker. 

Ice cream makers are becoming popular over the last couple of years. Expert says this happens because of increasing global warming. People are becoming more and more health-conscious. They try their best to avoid outside food, even ice cream.

In previous days, our Grandma’s were making ice cream occasionally just to enjoy the kitchenade work. However, these days ice cream lovers try their best to make home-made ice cream selecting the best ingredients, controlling the sugar or calories, and adding the natural fruits they like to eat. Additionally, today’s ice cream maker is not just an ice cream maker, you can prepare sorbet, gelato, or frozen yogurt as well.  

Ice cream makers are now crowned as an essential kitchen appliance like toaster or sandwich maker. So if you still run out of an ice cream maker, don’t delay to order one. Searching on the net may confuse you while selecting from different brands and models. Don’t worry- we make your task easy by searching 10 best ice cream makers considering the consumer rating and reviews as well as expert researches and commenting. Just rely on us!   

Why bother with home made ice cream? Because you can control the ingredients, you can use fresh fruit and luscious cream, and exclude all the artificial flavors and additives that you get in store bought ice cream.

Ice cream makers take the effort out of it, there’s an electric mixing paddle to beat the mixture stiff. The built in freezer bowls mean that the mixture cools immediately. This is homemade icecream with a gadget to do the tough bits.

Before go to the product list with details, you must have an overview idea of the buying guide or things that should be in mind while selecting an ice cream maker. 
# List of 5 ice cream makers – Editor’s Pick:

Buying Guide: 

You have to keep in mind some of the different things before you head out to make your purchase. In the old days, of course, the big hand-crank operated wooden bucket was the only option. Days past and technology grabs almost all other fields including kitchen appliances. Now, you can choose from a huge selection of different electric models. Few factors must be kept in mind before buying an ice cream maker. These factors include methods of freezing, price, size, and aesthetics.   

Methods of Freezing

Basic three types of freezing methods are in the market nowadays. Rock salt and ice method was the oldest method you can choose still these days, The freezer bowl method is more updated and the compressor method is for those who love to have ice cream frequently. 

Rock salt and ice method 

This was the only way that our grandmas were used to prepare ice cream back in the days. Are you interested in the nostalgia factor? You can still keep a big manual machine. However, a lot of grunt work or energetic young hands are required to prepare ice cream by this method. As an electric kitchen appliance user, probably you don’t want to contend with this manual process. Moreover, a good supply of salt and ice must be in hand at the time of preparing. 

Frozen bowl method 

This is another way where you need to pre-plan before making ice cream as you cannot go for a whim in this type. The basic structure of these types of machines is – an electrically-powered paddle and a bowl with the plastic outer layer and a metal inner layer that contains gel refrigerant or something liquid in between these. The bowl needs to pre-freeze 12 to 24 hours before going for an operation. Once the bowl is frozen, place it into the machine, pour in the ingredients, and churn it using the paddle. Ice cream becomes fairly soft by this method.   

Built-in- freezer or compressor method 

This method is the latest method of preparing ice cream with a fully automated system. This way is the best for convenience and recommended by the finest ice cream makers. No need to pre-freeze any part of the machine – thanks to the built-in chilling compressors. Just put your ingredients to the bowl, set the bowl to the right place, and switch on the machine and the machine does the rest. 

Size

Various quarts of capacities are available in the market. So you must keep in mind about your requirement whether you make ice cream for a full family or a party or you just need for your personal purpose.   

Price

One vital point that should be in mind is the price – a factor that narrows the field somewhat for most of us. You can purchase ice cream spending only 20 to 30 dollars. But remember 100 or more pricy machines are also available. So it depends on the – what features you really need, manual or fully automated, and also the size matters. Sometimes (again, not always) manufacturing quality depends upon price. 

Apart from these major factors, few more things must be kept in mind while buying an ice cream maker are – easy-to-use, texture and consistency, durability, noise level, easy cleaning, motor capacity or speed, add-in spout, and motor mounting position.

Top 10 Best Ice Cream Makers Reviews

1. Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Frozen Yogurt Ice cream maker

This is obvious that culinarian people are very much familiar with the brand Cuisinart. Whenever you are a dedicated churner or novice, Cuisinart might be your top choice. Cuisinart’s countertop appliance is universally recommended by experts. Cuisinart 1.5-quart ice cream maker could satisfy you with delicious yogurt or ice cream in hot sunny days. 

Within only 20 minutes this appliance can make ice cream using its powerful motor, unique mixing paddle, and double-insulated freezer bowl. The self-contained freezing system can freeze the ice cream faster. Because of its double-insulated freezer bowl, it doesn’t need extra ice for leftover preservation. 

More than 600 Bed Bath & Beyond shoppers have left excellent ratings by commenting on how easy to operate it. Easy lock system makes your tusk comfortable and transparent lid allows seeing the making progress without open the stuff again and again. Added large spout assist mixing ingredients keeping the device mess-free.    

These days kitchen appliance customer always looks for an automated system like – add ingredients to a bowl, press on the button and the machine do the rest. Cuisinart 1.5-quart ice cream maker is exactly like this type of automated stuff. Hope you would like it and will rate this as the best ice cream maker.  

Highlighted Features : 

  • Fully automatic
  • Fast output
  • 1.5-quart bowl capacity
  • Powerful motor
  • Unique mixing paddle
  • Double-insulated freezer bowl
  • Self-contained freezing system
  • Transparent lid
  • Large spout

2. Cuisinart ICE-30BC Pure Indulgence 2-Quart Automatic Frozen Yogurt, Sorbet, and Ice Cream Maker

If your budget is not an issue, then you could invest a little more to purchase a slightly larger capacity and polished looked Cuisinart ICE-30BC ice cream maker with a brushed chrome 2-quart option. Though the Cuisinart previous model and this one are the same, this gives you a more upscale look on the counter, and per batch, it gives half a quart more ice cream.  

Shiny silver appearance fitted a little better with a contemporary kitchen design. This silver model brings it a different look as the vast majority of other ice cream makers on the market are white. This smaller model Cuisinart appliance has the same heavy-duty motor as the other model has.   

The easy-lock lid is transparent to check the progress of the ice cream and easily be attached to the base. To add the ingredients like chocolate chips or caramel at any moment of the process, a large spout is contained. One thing should be mentioned that when you need to freeze a large amount of liquid, it does take a few more times to get to the required temperature. 

This larger capacity but the compact sized machine is a more appealing solution for those ice cream lovers who don’t envisage regular ice cream-making adventure.  

Highlighted Features : 

  • Fully automated
  • Brushed stainless-steel housing
  • Heavy-duty motor
  • BPA free
  • Double insulated 2-quart freezer bowl
  • Large ingredient spout for further mix-in 

3. Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart ICE-70 ice cream maker would be right at home in any modern kitchen because of its chrome finished appearance. It’s sleek and tall, but can be tucked into a corner for its narrow shape. If you leave the freezer bowl in the freezer, which is the heaviest component of the appliance, then the actual weight isn’t too heavy to keep on a high shelf. 

The function buttons could be your best friend or worst enemy. The manufacturer makes it simple with a start/pause button and easy modes for ice cream, gelato, or sorbet. Up and down arrows allow to set time while a pause option helps to add ingredients without resetting your timer- a feature certainly included an ice cream maker. 

Each dessert owned by a pre-programmed timer and the slightly slower option is the coolest feature on the gelato setting. Simply adjust your timer choosing a setting based on the required churn speed.

This ice cream maker may seem to look a bit pricy, but if you can swing the price then this could be worthwhile for its convenient features, especially for its gelato settings and built-in timer. If you are searching for an automated modern ice cream maker for your home, this unit won’t be disappointed you.     

Highlighted Features : 

  • Automated and manual modes
  • Built-in timer
  • Easy feature button with LCD screen 
  • Pause button to add mix-ins 
  • 2-quart capacity

4. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker

Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker

The Lello 4080 Musso Lussino ice cream maker is typically a shot of R234 refrigerant that is completely constructed with stainless steel including the outside frame, the freezing dish, and the dasher. Except for the working parts, there is plastic – on the knobs and cord.   

This machine features a built-in compressor, which can create multiple batches of frozen treats one right after the other with the assist of 100-watt powerful motor –attached directly to the bucket. 

The motor is on the base instead of the top so that you uncover the top lid without moving the motor again and again. This bottom mounted motor design allows full-size plastic cover covering the bowl. This design incorporates ingredients easily or helps in observing the freezing process.   

Just within 30 minutes, this sleek machine can make smooth and creamy batches of ice cream. Many users unanimously reviewed its ice cream the smoothest and best-flavored. 

If you are a casual dessert maker, then this unit could be too expensive because of its jaw-dropping price. However, if you look over its multi-features then this machine prices worthy. 

If you plan to make ice cream frequently, this might be the machine for you. 

Highlighted Features : 

  • Fully automatic
  • 1.5-quart bowl capacity
  • Timer control operation
  • Easy-to-clean
  • Stainless steel housing, bowl, paddle
  • 100-watt powerful motor

5. Nostalgia ICMP600WD Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

The Nostalgia ICMP600WD Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker makes it safe and simple to prepare up to 6 quarts of ice cream, gelato, or yogurt. You can try vanilla crème, chocolate, strawberry, and no sugar added vanilla by this perfectly worked ice cream maker.

It can be clean and wipe effortlessly because of it trashy design. An included handle makes this stuff easy carrying like a bag. Behind the exterior, a powerful electric motor does all the churning erasing the manual effort. Your job is to sit back and enjoy the ride! Here, during the ice cream making process, all parts are remain secured as the notches keep the motor in right place. 

The ice cream canister is transparent to see the progress without opening the lid. In only one sitting you can make up to 12 pounds of ice cream due to a lot of inner space. Store leftover ice cream in the freezer using the included lid and lid cap.   

The real wood slats exterior design feels the old fashioned ice cream making experience reminiscing of Grandma’s simple hand-crank ice cream maker. This brown wooded antic design brings additional beauty to your countertop. 

Highlighted Features : 

  • 6-quart capacity
  • Transparent lid
  • Powerful electric motor
  • Motor lock
  • Easy-to-clean
  • Real wood construction

6. Cuisinart ICE-45 Mix It In Soft Serve 1-1/2-Quart Ice Cream Maker

Do you need an ice cream maker that can make about 6-8 generous servings with a fully automated system? The Cuisinart ICE-45 Mix It in Soft Serve can fulfill your need. It can instinctively prepare sherbet, frozen yogurt, and another cold dessert of your choice. The three condiment dispenser is known as its key feature that allows you and your family to willingly choose three mix-ins; such as chocolate chips, sprinkles, crushed nuts, or candy. Simply it turns into soft serve by pouring in all the ingredients.     

The ice cream creation is possible due to its freezer bowl. If you need ice cream in a day or so, just you need to place the bowl in the freezer and enjoy quick use when you are ready. It’s ideal to store the bowl permanently in the freezer when you decide not to use it. Extra bowls are available in the market, so if you plan on making two kinds of ice cream simultaneously, you can keep an extra on hand.  

This culinary item can be separated part by part for easy clean-up. You can keep this stuff sparkling and bacteria-free by washing with soap and a little warm water. 

Highlighted Features : 

  • Easy lock lid with window 
  • Mixing arm for automated mixing
  • Rubber feet to resist slipping during operation
  • 1.5-quart freezing bowl
  • Three condiment containers
  • Cone holder and on/off power dial
  • Fully automatic 
  • Easy to clean 

7. Elite Gourmet EIM-502 4-quart Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Maker

The first thing you will notice about the Elite Gourmet EIM-502 ice cream maker is its old fashioned design. So if you want to beautify your countertop with a fashionable accessory then this is well worth checking out. Its handcrafted pinewood bucket design brings a different look brightening up the kitchen. 

This kitchen stuff is made up of an aluminum freezing canister. So you will be able to freeze the ice cream very quickly. The operating system of this heavy-duty aluminum freezing canister is so easy even a beginner can easily handle this appliance. Within 40 minutes you will get four quarts of ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt, or sorbet; enough for a birthday party.  

This machine features a maple finish pine tub made by strong galvanized hoops, 3500rpm high-performance motor with overheating protection system, and two functions design is also featured allowing easy conversion from automatic to manual hand crank. 

This dishwasher safe appliance whips creamy consistency by using a powerful electric motor-driven paddle. Consumers who have already used this stuff gave very good ratings considering not only its fashionable compact design but the user-friendly operation with high-performance duty. 

Highlighted Features : 

  • Four quarts capacity
  • Handcrafted solid pine wood bucket 
  • Easy to operate and clean
  • Great for barbeques, family parties, and picnics
  • Heavy-duty aluminum freezing canister
  • Powerful electric motor 
  • Both automatic and manual hand crank options 

8. Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker

Nostalgia ICMP400BLUE is manufactured with the idea of an old-fashioned ice cream maker. With this fun machine, large batches of ice cream can be made. Though its freezing system is just like an old-style ice cream maker, the cranking mechanism is electric, so you don’t need to worry about working hard to get your treats.

This bucket designed ice cream maker is made from plastic and with the use of included lid, the storage container becomes doubled. This machine is contained with a handle for easy transportation. And for securing all parts a motor lock, used when the power is off, is also included.  

If you are a beginner and want to make your work easy, the company makes mixes which are to be used with the machine or can be used any ice cream recipes or one of your own. It can produce decent ice cream with a lower overrun of 31%. Four quarts of ice cream is plenty enough for parties! 

This kitchen stuff made up of simple construction, with a cover, a bucket, a canister, a dasher, and a motor fitting over the top. The operation is also easy, just plug in and off. However, remember this machine is not designed to add mix-ins while in operation.  

Highlighted Features : 

  • Can make 4 quarts of ice cream
  • A see-thru lid is in included to store leftover ice cream
  • A carrying handle
  • Electric motor locks
  • Easy to wash 

9. Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker

If you are searching for an ice cream maker that gives you lots of ice cream and you hate the idea of hand-churning, then Hamilton Beach 68330N is perfect for you. Within 20 to 40 minutes it can make 4 quarts of ice cream. 

This automatic ice cream maker doesn’t need any settings or controls. To begin the churning, just plug the machine in. The machine turns off automatically when the mixer is so thick. Now the ice cream is ready to finish firming up by entering into the freezer. Your job is to stay nearby so that you can see or listen for the churning to stop. You won’t face any trouble getting the churning sound as this machine is a bit louder compared to the more expensive compressor-style ice cream makers.   

A specially formulated liquid assists working of the freezer bowl which is stored in between the insulating layers of the mixing bowl. It starts working once the liquid is fully frozen.    

The total package includes a recipe book with 20 delicious recipes. Ideas are given in such an easy way so that beginners can start without taking pain. A helpful attachment! 

Highlighted Features : 

  • Fully automatic
  • Large capacity 
  • Lightweight
  • Easy-lock lid
  • A budget buy

10. Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker  

Are you serious about making ice cream? Get ready with this model! Yes, though it comes with a steep price tag, it has several benefits too. To freeze the ice cream while it churns, this 1.5-quart ice cream maker contains a compressor just like a window air conditioner. This unit assures you not to worry about freezing and refreezing a bowl between batches.  

For different levels of softness 12 specifically, settings are calibrated that brings an added benefit of this model. A pre-cool setting helps the machine immediate start churning and to keep the temperature in the right position internal thermometers work throughout the operation. Reviewers should follow the filling instructions and try not to overfill it unless you decide to clean up a mess of melted ice cream.   

The Breville’s tubs are completely removable (with extras available for purchase). This unit is designed with bottom mount motor and full-size removable plastic cover so that the user doesn’t need to feed extra ingredients through a channel. 

We got available ice cream makers with chrome finishes, but stainless steel is an infrequent feature. Moreover, compared to the other ice cream maker with similar features, this appliance is truly inexpensive. 

Highlighted Features : 

  • Takes less time
  • 1.5-quart capacity
  • 12 hardness settings
  • Adjustable alarms and volume
  • Easy-to-read screen 

How To Clean An Ice Cream Machine

You’ve made all your favorite ice cream in the summertime. You enjoyed with your family and now packed up the leftover in the freeze for storing, you can just lay on rocking chair and relax…right? Wrong! Once you’ve finished making a creation, don’t forget to clean up your ice cream maker.

Now, you need to know how to clean, but before moving to in deep let’s review why you need to clean your machine:

  • To prevent bacteria from calling your ice cream machine home
  • Resist flavor mixing to your next recipe 
  • To keep the machine running at maximum performance

As you know the importance of cleaning after using each time, so it can easily get the importance of the factor ‘convenience of using and cleaning on a regular basis’ while buying the machine.  

The compressor models are made with stainless steel and the only washable parts (not in the dishwasher) are the detachable plastic dashers and metal canisters. Cuisinart ICE and Breville models were especially easy to clean and turn into usable in minutes. To clean the hard-to-reach canister cylinder, Breville comes up with its small brush. Once the ICE’s were defrosted the freezer bowl, it also becomes easily washable.

You may face a couple of problems with Musso as the metal dasher is the only removable part and during churning it freezes tight, making it difficult to remove before spreading it with hot water. The Musso’s manual instructed pouring hot water into the bowl, stay ten minutes, and with a sponge wipe it out and repeat the process several times until all soapy residues were removed properly. 

Hamilton Beach’s canister and dasher are easy to remove and wash. However, removing ice and saltwater from the unit’s bucket is a bit tricky not to spill it everywhere.  

To make your work easy we are presenting five steps of cleaning your ice cream maker.

1. Empty : First of all your machine need to completely free from any leftover mess from its body or blades. 

2. Flush: Spray water through your machine. Make sure water should get through the machine without any blockage. Repeat step one if there is a blockage anywhere.  

3. Disassemble: literally, this step seems to you tedious, but don’t forget to wash your machine as clean as possible. 

Detach all moving and non-moving parts that came in contact with ingredients during operation. 

4. Soak and Scrub: Soaking the parts in warm, soapy water is the easiest way to wash your machine. You can use a soft brush or sponge to remove all debris thoroughly. Then, rinse those parts in cool water and let dry. 

 5. Reassemble: Once all the parts dried completely, you have to reassemble the parts properly. If you face any trouble, follow the user manual. Now, your machine is ready for future use!  

Ice cream maker varies one from another. So the cleaning process could also differ from machine to machine. Here, our suggestion is to read the user manual carefully to have a deep overview of your machine – will lead you in the right way how to clean yours. 

How Does An Ice Cream Machine Work ? 

The process of making ice cream seems like a basic one, what happens behind the scenes could be confusing and tough to understand if you aren’t an engineer. Continuously mixing milk and sweetened cream (called ingredients) in a freezing environment is the basic principle of making ice cream. Preventing the formation of ice crystals by mixing and blending the ingredients, thereby give the final smooth texture. 

An electric motor is the most important part of an ice cream maker. There are four types of machines with different mechanisms as follows.

Counter top Ice Cream Maker

This machine comes with a double-walled bowl; metal finished in the inner layer and plastic make the outer layer. In between these two layers, there are liquid urea and distilled water. After freezing the bowl, it is installed into the machine. Then ingredients keep on the bowl and start rotating after triggering the paddles. The mixture comes in contact with the frozen wall of the bowl and started freezing the ingredients. 

Freezer Unit Ice Cream Maker​

This machine is not contained with a double-walled bowl like the previous one, though it nearly resembles the countertop variety. Just place it into a freezer and plug it on, its paddle starts mixing ingredients until reach to the desired consistency. You can make multiple batches of ice cream frequently as it doesn’t need to pre-freeze the bowl. 

Built-In Ice Cream Maker​

This type of ice cream maker is known as the largest and most efficient. Simply switch on the machine and stay a couple of minutes to run, and then pour the ingredients for paddling. It takes about 20 minutes to prepare. You don’t need to wait for this session because of the built-in coolants. One thing should be remembering that these machines cannot be moved for 12 hours before use it as that would cause disturbance of the freezing system. 

Ice and Salt Ice Maker​

This old fashioned ice cream maker holds ice cream mixture in a bowl filled the outer tub with salt and ice. It can blend with a speed up to 75RPM. An upper mounted motor rotates the canisters and keeps the churning paddle in a fixed place. The mixture freezing depends on the rate of canisters rotation. Gradually, a counter-rotating scraper mixes all the ice returning from the walls by re-introducing it into the mixture. This process continues to get the final result of thick and smooth ice cream.  

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How long does the bowl need to keep in the freezer before first-time use? 

Answer: It is recommended that before the first time uses the bowl should be kept for 24 hours in advance and not to remove until you are ready to use it. However, this time varies from one model to another. Here, it is better to follow the manual instruction strictly.   

If the ice cream maker stops working during the operation, then what should I do?  

Answer: Overheating is one of the major problems why your ice cream maker stops working this way. Like another electric device, ice cream maker also has a safety cut-out feature that stops the motor of the machine in any unusual situation including overheating. So, allow your machine to cool after using a certain time. Actually, this happens when you operate the machine for a long time.  

How can I achieve the best results from my ice cream maker?  

Answer: Pre-freezing is a method you can get the best result from your ice cream maker. Before freezing, ensure the bowl is properly dried. Keep the bowl upright while in the freezer. Make sure your ingredients are refrigerated before mix-in. Avoid alcohol to your recipe to keep the freezing process away from inhibits. 

How long would it take to make ice cream? 

Answer: Usually 15 -30 minutes. Duration depends all about the ingredients, amount, and obviously, it varies from one machine to another.

How much does it cost to make ice cream?   

Answer: Two factors determine the cost of your ice cream. The first one is the cost of your machine and it depends on all about your choice. The second one is the ingredients you would like to use. This depends on what type of ice cream do you want. If you opt for organic high-quality ingredients, you have to spend more on ice cream. Another thing should be kept in mind that electricity consumed by ice cream maker relay on motor power. More rated powerful motor require more electricity causes more electricity bills. Many of the users (usually non-commercial users) forget to calculate this bill while thinking of the cost of ice cream.     

Conclusion

If you are capable of selecting and buying the right machine, your spending money is a price worthy investment. We found tremendous advantages in keeping an ice cream maker at home. Home-made ice cream is cheaper and healthier than those found in the store. 

No matter you choose a pricey machine or a cheaper model; you can start your journey of preparing your healthy desserts at the comfort of your home. You don’t need to be an expert. The user manual will lead you to prepare yourself as a nearly expert ice cream maker. 

You have already familiar with the top ten best ice cream makers. You know the factors that play role varying ice cream maker one to another. You are enriched with lots of information and got an overview idea of different ice cream makers. This time choose your eyes! Order now in no time, get it, make a recipe of your own and enjoy this summer!    

Comments are closed.