Beef Broth Vs Beef Consomme & 3 Beef Consomme Substitute

by Daisy Dao

One of the most important parts in a soup or stew is broth.

The flavoring of the broth determines nearly everything else in a dish such as this. If your broth is not flavorful, it will drag the rest of your dish down.

While making a broth is not difficult, there exists a certain kind of broth that is truly impressive and that will enhance any kind of soup or stew.

Enter consomme, a certain kind of broth that is much more complicated but beats any kind of broth in terms of flavor.

It takes a lot of ingredients to make beef consommé. Is it possible to find anything like it that is not as complicated to make?

The refreshing answer to this question is that there do exist substitutes for this extremely complex but fantastic type of broth.

Beef Broth Vs Beef Consomme & 3 Beef Consomme Substitute
Beef Broth Vs Beef Consomme & 3 Beef Consomme Substitute

3 Beef Consomme Alternative

Broth With Beef And Soup
Broth With Beef And Soup

1. Beef broth

Beef broth is one of the most famous substitutes for consomme. It can be done in different ways, the best option is to do it in your own home using everything you need, such as the bones of the cow itself, along with the vegetables that each one considers necessary. Another option we have is to buy it in the supermarket in packages as already prepared broth, or in cubes to give flavour to meals.

Of course, you should keep in mind that the best opportunity is to make the broth yourself since it will offer us a very good flavour

To make a good homemade beef broth, you must cook the bones of the cow for about 30 minutes. Later, we are going to fill the container with all kinds of vegetables such as celery, carrot or chopped onion among other options. Thus, during the time that you stipulate depending on the flavour you want to transmit.

This methodology will allow us to have a gelatinous texture within the liquid itself.

Beef Broth.
Beef Broth.


2. The beef broth cooked in a pot

The beef broth from scratch is the most suitable alternative to consomme without a doubt. This is because it provides us with all the flavor we need for our meals.

The meat profile between the consomme and the broth is very similar, however, the broth has a lower flavor intensity. This process will be solved by cooking it over low heat for half an hour. It is because the liquid will evaporate and the flavor will increase.

The Beef Broth Cooked In A Pot
The Beef Broth Cooked In A Pot

3. The mushroom

This has a large number of variants, it can be made with meat, but also with cannons or fresh vegetables.

If you are a vegan, you can introduce all kinds of silver and vegetables to alleviate the use of meat. In this way, this consomme is a good option to try to match the flavor of the meat in such a way that it is not necessary to introduce anything of the same beef.

An example is the preparation of consomme with mushrooms, the combination to be used will be white mushrooms, it will be the best option to give more flavor.

The Mushroom
The Mushroom

Difference between meat broth and consomme

There are some differences between consomm & broth, they are the following:

The color: the meat broth has a brownish color and a cloudy liquid, something that is achieved by simmering with the vegetables and meat.

The consistency: the broth is much finer than the consomme

Taste: the consomme; will taste better than the meat.

Concentration: the consomme; is more concentrated than the broth. This will be seen with the naked eye.

Uses: a consomme is a good option for an aperitif, or as a preparation for other dishes. The meat broth to make sauces or soups among other possibilities.

Beef Consomme Recipe

It is a very simple option to do at home and it will not take us a great deal of time. You must bear in mind that for the flavour to be the best possible, you will have to buy all the fresh produce in a butcher shop, instead of taking it packaged in the supermarket. In this way, we are going to use the best parts to make our broth. Now we see you tell how we will do it and what we will need for it.


– 4 egg whites.

– 1 tablespoon of black pepper.

– 4 stalks of celery.

– 4 tomatoes.

– Crane to taste.

– 1 tablespoon of salt.

– 1 branch of rosemary.

– 1 branch of thyme,

– 6 cups of beef broth.


The way to make this consomme is as follows:

  • Add the egg and the pepper in a bowl, we will beat it until obtaining the foam.
  • We go on to cut the vegetables, in this case, the celery, tomatoes and ground meat.
  • We will put all the ingredients in a pot to heat it over low heat. You are going to have to move everything from time to time. When it starts to boil, you have to lower the heat so that it cooks for a little over half an hour.
  • We will remove them from the heat and pour the liquid with a strainer.
  • It is seasoned with whatever we want to serve it warm.


The complicated process of making beef consomme

Anybody who has made beef consomme knows what making it entails.

  1. In order to make beef consomme, you need to be prepared to spend a lot of time and money on the dozens of ingredients that are necessary.
  2. The first thing you need to make beef consomme is beef stock. This alone takes a very long time to make, and making the stock itself requires you to gather and simmer roasted beef bones, celery, carrots, onions, tomato puree, and various herbs and spices.
  3. This needs to sit for hours before it can be made into a consomme, which involves another process in and of itself.
  4. To convert your beef stock into beef consomme, you need to simmer the stock with egg whites and lean ground meat. This is a completely separate process from making the beef stock itself.
  5. Making the stock and then converting it to consomme will take an entire day. This is how complicated, time consuming, and costly making beef consomme can be and it is why it is a good thing to seek out substitutes.

What to expect in beef consomme substitutes

As mentioned earlier, making beef consomme from scratch is extremely complicated. It is also rare to find it prepackaged in stores, so there is a good amount of demand for things that you use in place of beef consomme that has a similar flavor and texture.

Here are a few things that you might want to know when choosing a substitute.

Beef consomme is such a complicated broth that you will probably not find a perfect substitute. This is especially true if you are looking for a substitute for beef consomme that you have made from scratch.

It can even be difficult to find a perfect substitute for prepackaged beef consomme, but if you are looking for substitutes for prepackaged beef consomme, you will not notice a difference. You should still be able to use these substitutes for beef consomme for french onion soup or anything like it.

What To Expect In Beef Consomme Substitutes
What To Expect In Beef Consomme Substitutes

Is beef consomme the same as beef broth?

Before exploring these substitutes, it is first necessary to know why you might need a substitute for beef consomme.

First, you probably just do not want to take the time and effort to make it from scratch and you cannot find any prepackaged beef consommé. This is probably the most common reason.

Another reason is because you prefer a vegetarian or vegan broth. Beef consomme is made with beef stock, and if you follow a vegetarian diet but still want to experience the distinct flavor of beef consommé.

These are two major reasons for why you will need a substitute. The following substitutes keep both of these reasons in mind.

The first substitute for beef consomme is to just make the beef broth that is made before converting it to consomme and just stop there. If you are just using beef consomme as a base, chances are good that you will be able to get the same kind of effect with beef broth.

If you are buying beef consomme at a store and need something to replace it, there is nothing wrong with going with beef bouillon cubes. These are usually just as flavorful in a broth as beef consomme is, at last when it comes to using it as a soup base.

Making beef consomme from scratch is a complicated process, but it does not need to be even more complicated if you want to make a vegetarian option. All you need to do to maintain the same flavor is swap out anything beef related with mushroom related ingredients. You’ll get the same kind of flavor and it is completely vegan friendly.

These are just two practical substitutes for beef consomme. It is not difficult to find substitutes like these. All you need is to understand what you are using your beef consomme for and be creative enough to change up some ingredients.

Is Beef Consomme The Same As Beef Broth
Is Beef Consomme The Same As Beef Broth

The Vertdict

If you are making it from scratch, there is no real substitute for beef consomme, especially if you are using it as a first course meal. The ingredients all just fit too well, and nothing can replace how these ingredients come together.

However, substitutes exist if you are not serving beef consomme as a first course meal and instead using it as a soup broth. If this is the case, you can usually just go with beef broth. There is no reason to complicate things any more if all you want is a quality soup base.

Mushroom broth is also a very good alternative if you still want that signature beef consomme taste but follow a vegetarian diet. Mushroom broth is only a little less flavorful than beef consomme, but you will not notice much of a difference.

Do not let the complicated recipe of beef consomme intimidate you if you are looking for substitutes. If you know what you are using your beef consomme for and are willing to make some changes, it is easy to come up with substitutes for it.

About Daisy Dao

Daisy grew up on the beautiful Honolulu island where she often found herself spending most of her day enjoying the ocean scent in sea waves. As such, Daisy came to appreciate the art of cooking seafood. She has experimented with baking, roasting, broiling, poaching, grilling (and every other cooking technique you can think of); and with all kinds of spices too. Now she is ready to present her experience: the art of cooking healthy food without any pre-packaged ingredients; food product recommendations for people who need a bit more guidance on what goes into their bodies; how to maintain an active lifestyle without having to give up your favorite foods!

Be with Daisy:

Leave a Reply

Check for FREE Gifts. Or get our Free Cookbooks right now.

Disable the Ad Block to reveal all the recipes. Once done that, click on any button below